Aspects of Alterity: Levinas, Marcel, and the Contemporary by Brian Treanor

By Brian Treanor

Any other is really different, yet no different is entirely other.This is the declare that facets of Alterity defends. taking on the query of otherness that so fascinates modern continental philosophy, this booklet asks what it potential for anything or somebody to be except the self. Levinas and people motivated through him indicate that the philosophical culture of the West has often favourite the self on the price of the opposite. this type of self-centered point of view by no means encounters the opposite qua different, even though. In reaction, postmodern notion insists at the absolute otherness of the opposite, epitomized through the deconstructive declare any other is thoroughly other.But absolute otherness generates difficulties and aporias of its personal. This has led a few thinkers to reevaluate the idea of relative otherness in mild of the postmodern critique, arguing for a chiastic account that does justice to either the alterity and the similitude of the opposite. those latter positions-absolute otherness and a rehabilitated account of relative otherness-are the most contenders within the modern debate.The philosophies of Emmanuel Levinas and Gabriel Marcel give you the element of embarkation for coming to appreciate the 2 positions in this query. Levinas and Marcel have been contemporaries whose philosophies express remarkably comparable obstacle for the opposite yet however stay essentially incompatible. therefore, those thinkers offer a remarkable representation of either the proximity of and the unbridgeable hole among debts of otherness.Aspects of Alterity delves into this debate, first so as comprehend the problems at stake in those positions and moment to figure out which description higher bills for the adventure of encountering the other.After a radical evaluation and critique of otherness in Levinas's and Marcel's paintings, together with a dialogue of the connection of moral alterity to theological assumptions, features of Alterity lines the transmission and improvement of those conceptions of otherness. Levinas's model of otherness could be noticeable within the paintings of Jacques Derrida and John D. Caputo, whereas Marcel's figuring out of otherness affects the paintings of Paul Ricoeur and Richard Kearney.Ultimately, points of Alterity makes a case for a hermeneutic account of otherness. Otherness itself isn't absolute, yet is a chiasm of alterity and similitude. adequately articulated, such an account is able to addressing the valid moral and epistemological matters that lead thinkers to construe otherness in absolute phrases, yet with no absolutely the aporiasthat accompany this kind of characterization.

Show description

Read Online or Download Aspects of Alterity: Levinas, Marcel, and the Contemporary Debate (Perspectives in Continental Philosophy) PDF

Similar philosophy books

Secrets of Becoming: Negotiating Whitehead, Deleuze, and Butler

Secrets and techniques of changing into brings into dialog modes of inspiration characteristically held aside: Whitehead's philosophy of the development, Deleuze's philosophy of multiplicity, and Judith Butler's philosophy of gender distinction. Why should still one try and attach those traces of pondering? What may perhaps make the paintings of those thinkers negotiable with each other?

On Vision and Colors: Color Sphere

Writer notice: Translated via Georg Stahl

During the 1st 20 years of the 19th century, of the main major theoretical works on colour in view that Leonardo da Vinci's Trattato della Pittura have been written and released in Germany: Arthur Schopenhauer's On imaginative and prescient and hues and Philipp Otto Runge's colour Sphere. For Schopenhauer, imaginative and prescient is utterly subjective in nature and characterised by way of strategies that move over into the territory of philosophy. Runge's colour Sphere and essay The Duality of colour contained one of many first makes an attempt to depict a finished and harmonious colour procedure in 3 dimensions. Runge meant his colour sphere to be understood now not as a made of artwork, yet quite as a mathematical determine of varied philosophical reflections. by means of bringing those visionary colour theories jointly inside of a vast theoretical context—philosophy, artwork, structure, and design—this quantity uncovers their enduring impact on our personal belief of colour and the visible global round us.

Free Will: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

On a daily basis we appear to make and act upon all types of selections: a few trivial, others so consequential that they alter the process one's lifestyles, or maybe the process historical past. yet are those offerings relatively loose, or are we forced to behave the best way we do via elements past our regulate? Is the sensation that shall we have made diversified judgements simply an phantasm?

A Companion To Schopenhauer (Blackwell Companions To Philosophy)

"A significant other to Schopenhauer" offers a finished advisor to the entire very important features of Schopenhauer's philosophy. the amount includes 26 newly commissioned essays by means of admired Schopenhauer students operating within the box this present day. A completely complete advisor to the existence, paintings, and considered Arthur Schopenhauer Demonstrates the variety of Schopenhauer's paintings and illuminates the debates it has generated 26 newly commissioned essays through essentially the most famous Schopenhauer students operating at the present time replicate the very most modern developments in Schopenhauer scholarship Covers the entire variety of ancient and philosophical views on Schopenhauer's paintings Discusses his seminal contributions to our figuring out of data, notion, morality, technology, good judgment and arithmetic, Platonic principles, the subconscious, aesthetic adventure, paintings, shades, sexuality, will, compassion, pessimism, tragedy, excitement, and happiness

Extra resources for Aspects of Alterity: Levinas, Marcel, and the Contemporary Debate (Perspectives in Continental Philosophy)

Sample text

Desire is never satisfied, is not even capable of satisfaction. Unlike need, it never grasps and consumes an other that would correspond to and satiate it. An encounter with the desired other only further deepens desire. What fits this criteria, that of a desire that can never be satisfied? Only the idea of infinity. Descartes already discovered the implications of the infinite in the Third Meditation. According to Levinas, Descartes’s most significant contribution was to show, in the analysis of the infinite, the impossibility of Platonic maieutics.

16272$ $CH2 11-20-06 13:59:43 PS 35 PAGE 35 along. ’’70 I only encounter the other qua other in responsibility, and in some sense these two terms are synonymous, or perhaps simultaneous. The recognition of the other is responsibility, is ethical. It is only when I recognize my responsibility that I encounter the other as other. If I do not recognize the other qua other, I do not recognize my responsibility; if I do not recognize my responsibility, I do not see the other qua other. While we may interact with other people in manners that degrade or even kill, in doing so the face of the other is not acknowledged—it is rejected.

If this is the case, then it is clear that otherness cannot be accounted for by ontology—as otherness is not absolute for ontology and is ultimately reduced to sameness—and, if ontology cannot account for the other, it cannot be primordial. The encounter with the other who is radically other and not merely relatively other cannot be accounted for in a system of intentionality wherein noesis always 16 Aspects of Alterity ................. 16272$ $CH2 11-20-06 13:59:33 PS PAGE 16 correlates with noema.

Download PDF sample

Aspects of Alterity: Levinas, Marcel, and the Contemporary by Brian Treanor
Rated 4.41 of 5 – based on 35 votes