Beyond Foucault New Perspectives on Bentham's Panopticon

In his highly influential ebook self-discipline and Punish, Foucault used the instance of Jeremy Bentham's Panopticon legal as a method of representing the transition from the early glossy monarchy to the past due glossy capitalist nation. within the former, energy is visibly exerted, for example by way of the destruction of the physique of the felony, whereas within the latter strength turns into invisible and specializes in the brain of the topic, which will determine, marginalize, and 'treat' people who are considered as incapable of partaking in, or unwilling to undergo, the disciplines of construction. The Panopticon hyperlinks the worlds of Bentham and Foucault students but they can be at cross-purposes; with Bentham students lamenting the ways that Foucault is seemed to have misunderstood panopticon, and Foucauldians it sounds as if blind to the complexities of Bentham's idea. This booklet combines an appreciation of Bentham's broader undertaking with an engagement of Foucault's insights on fiscal executive to move past the got examining of panopticism as a gloomy disciplinary know-how of energy. students right here supply new methods of knowing the Panopticon tasks via a large choice of subject matters together with Bentham's plural Panopticons and their elaboration of schemes of 'panoptic Utopia', the 'inverted Panopticon', 'panoptic governance', 'political panopticism' and 'legal panopticism'. French reports at the Panopticon are groundbreaking and this publication brings this examine to an English-speaking viewers for the 1st time. it really is crucial examining, not just for these learning Bentham and Foucault, but in addition people with an curiosity in highbrow heritage of the eighteenth and 19th centuries, and people learning modern surveillance and society.

Contents: Foreword, Clare O'Farrell; creation, Anne Brunon-Ernst; half I Historiography Reconsidered: from self-discipline to Governmentality: Deconstructing Panopticism into the plural Panopticons, Anne Brunon-Ernst; From self-discipline and Punish to The start of Biopolitics, Christian Laval. half II prestige of the Panopticon in criminal, Penal and Constitutional Reform: From 'utopia' to 'programme': construction a Panopticon in Geneva, Emmanuelle de Champs; Penal concept with no the Panopticon, Jean-Pierre Cléro; From the penal complex to the political Panoptic paradigm, Guillaume Tusseau. half III Is There a Panoptic Society? Social keep watch over in Bentham and Foucault: Transparency and politics: the reversed Panopticon as a reaction to abuse of strength, Marie-Laure Leroy; Social keep an eye on and the criminal Panoptic paradigm, Malik Bozzo-Rey; Epilogue: the Panopticon as a modern icon?, Anne Brunon-Ernst and Guillaume Tusseau; Bibliography; Index.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Foucault New Perspectives on Bentham's Panopticon PDF

Similar philosophy books

Secrets of Becoming: Negotiating Whitehead, Deleuze, and Butler

Secrets and techniques of changing into brings into dialog modes of inspiration generally held aside: Whitehead's philosophy of the development, Deleuze's philosophy of multiplicity, and Judith Butler's philosophy of gender distinction. Why should still one try and attach those lines of pondering? What may possibly make the paintings of those thinkers negotiable with each other?

On Vision and Colors: Color Sphere

Writer be aware: Translated through Georg Stahl

During the 1st twenty years of the 19th century, of the main major theoretical works on colour in view that Leonardo da Vinci's Trattato della Pittura have been written and released in Germany: Arthur Schopenhauer's On imaginative and prescient and colours and Philipp Otto Runge's colour Sphere. For Schopenhauer, imaginative and prescient is absolutely subjective in nature and characterised by means of techniques that move over into the territory of philosophy. Runge's colour Sphere and essay The Duality of colour contained one of many first makes an attempt to depict a complete and harmonious colour approach in 3 dimensions. Runge meant his colour sphere to be understood no longer as a manufactured from artwork, yet quite as a mathematical determine of varied philosophical reflections. by way of bringing those visionary colour theories jointly inside a extensive theoretical context—philosophy, artwork, structure, and design—this quantity uncovers their enduring impact on our personal belief of colour and the visible international round us.

Free Will: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

On a daily basis we appear to make and act upon every kind of selections: a few trivial, others so consequential that they modify the process one's existence, or maybe the process historical past. yet are those offerings particularly loose, or are we pressured to behave the best way we do via elements past our keep watch over? Is the sensation that shall we have made various judgements simply an phantasm?

A Companion To Schopenhauer (Blackwell Companions To Philosophy)

"A better half to Schopenhauer" presents a accomplished advisor to all of the vital features of Schopenhauer's philosophy. the amount comprises 26 newly commissioned essays by means of widespread Schopenhauer students operating within the box this present day. A completely finished advisor to the lifestyles, paintings, and regarded Arthur Schopenhauer Demonstrates the diversity of Schopenhauer's paintings and illuminates the debates it has generated 26 newly commissioned essays by means of probably the most trendy Schopenhauer students operating this present day replicate the very newest tendencies in Schopenhauer scholarship Covers the whole variety of old and philosophical views on Schopenhauer's paintings Discusses his seminal contributions to our figuring out of information, notion, morality, technological know-how, common sense and arithmetic, Platonic principles, the subconscious, aesthetic adventure, artwork, shades, sexuality, will, compassion, pessimism, tragedy, excitement, and happiness

Extra resources for Beyond Foucault New Perspectives on Bentham's Panopticon

Example text

5 Nevertheless, the importance of Discipline and Punish in reviving interest in Bentham’s Panopticon should not be underestimated. Most people in Europe and the United States have read Bentham’s Panopticon through the lens of Foucault’s work on the prison system. Ironically, Foucault’s massive contribution to the revival of interest in the Panopticon has created significant problems for Bentham scholars, since Foucault’s work misrepresents Bentham and his project. Foucault’s interpretation has even provided critical vocabulary with a new Benthamesque adjective – ‘panoptic’6 – the application of which strikes fear in the heart of every freedom-loving individual.

The later chapter 3 in Discipline and Punish exhibits the same features two years later. See a similar description of the Panopticon in Foucault, ‘The Eye of Power’. 46 See the Epilogue, pp. 191–3. 51 As Laval discusses below, Foucault comes to such a conclusion on Bentham’s works in his lecture series The Birth of Biopolitics, although not basing himself on the Panopticon writings. I contend here that a closer reading of the plural Panopticons yields governmentality as well as disciplinary power.

103–4. Semple, Bentham’s Prison, p. 34, and Semple, ‘Bentham’s Haunted House’, p. 40. 57 Foucault, Psychiatric Power, pp. 48–52. 55 56 Deconstructing Panopticism into the Plural Panopticons 33 for one and a universal constitutional code for the other. Moreover, the constitutional-Panopticon does not allow citizens to register the government’s activities, thanks to procedures which are specifically inscribed in the panoptic architecture. One last panoptic feature is the isotopic system. Foucault writes: [A] disciplinary power is isotopic or, at least, tends towards isotopy.

Download PDF sample

Beyond Foucault New Perspectives on Bentham's Panopticon
Rated 4.16 of 5 – based on 48 votes